10 Things to Consider When Selecting a Property Management Company in San Diego

Thinking about hiring a property manager to manage your property and free up your valuable time?  We explore some important considerations.


Owning a property can be a rewarding investment, but managing it effectively can be a daunting task. That's where a reliable San Diego property management company comes in. With their expertise and resources in rental properties, they can handle the day-to-day operations, making your life as a homeowner much easier. But how do you choose the right San Diego, CA property management company for your needs to make sure you are getting one of the top San Diego property management companies? In this blog post, we'll explore the top things to consider when selecting a property management company in San Diego.

Choosing the right management company for your home is a crucial decision that can significantly impact your investment. It's important to entrust your property to a company that understands your goals and will provide exceptional service. Let's dive into the key factors to consider when selecting a property manager.

Reputation and Experience

One of the first things to consider when selecting a property management company is their reputation and experience. When looking for property management services look for a company with a strong track record in managing properties, particularly in San Diego County. Check online reviews, ask for referrals, and research their history to get a better understanding of their reputation. It's also essential to consider how long they have been in business and their experience with properties similar to yours.

Online reviews are a powerful tool when assessing the credibility of a property manager. A wealth of information can be found on websites that collect and display customer experiences. Several sites can provide insights into the experiences of other property owners with the company in question. Websites like Google Reviews, Yelp, and Better Business Bureau often feature reviews for professional property management companies in San Diego. These platforms allow you to view the company's overall rating and read detailed feedback from other property owners.

Services Offered

Different property management companies offer various services, so it's crucial to understand what is included in their package. Some may only provide basic services such as rent collection and tenant screening, while others offer full-service management, including maintenance and repairs. Consider your specific needs as a property owner and choose a company that can fulfill them adequately. Additionally, it's essential to clarify any additional fees or charges for services not included in the standard package. Transparency and clear communication are key when selecting a property management company.

Communication, Accessibility, & Responsiveness

Another crucial aspect to consider is the company's communication methods and accessibility. As a property owner, you want to have open and transparent communication with your property manager at all times. Make sure to inquire about their preferred communication methods, response time, and availability after hours. It's essential to establish clear expectations from the beginning to ensure a smooth working relationship.

Contracts and Pricing

Be sure to thoroughly review the management contract before signing it. Look for any hidden fees or clauses that may not align with your goals as a property owner having a rental property. Additionally, consider the company's pricing structure and how it compares to other management companies in the area. It's essential to choose a company that offers competitive pricing without sacrificing quality services. There are several types of fees that you might encounter, each serving a different purpose.

    • Management Fee – The management fee is the most common and is usually a percentage of the monthly rent revenue. The industry standard ranges from 8% to 12%, but this can vary based on the property type and location. This fee covers the cost of day-to-day operations such as rent collection, tenant communication, and routine inspections.
    • Leasing Fee – Some property management companies charge a leasing fee every time they find a new tenant for your property. This fee usually equates to a percentage of the first month's rent and covers the cost of marketing the property, showing it to potential tenants, and processing lease documents.
    • Maintenance Fee – In some cases, a company might charge a separate fee for maintenance services. This could be a flat rate or a mark-up on the actual cost of repairs. It's worth noting that not all companies charge this fee, so it's something to look out for during your comparison.
    • Vacancy Fee – A vacancy fee is less common, but some property management companies do charge a small monthly fee when the property is unoccupied. The intent is to cover the cost of keeping the property market-ready.

Remember, transparency in pricing is crucial. A reputable property management company will be upfront about all fees and ensure you fully understand what you're paying for your rental property.


Local Knowledge and Experience

Choosing a property manager one with local knowledge and experience is crucial. They will have a better understanding of the local market and can advise on rental rates, property regulations, and potential challenges unique to the area. This knowledge and experience can save you time, money, and headaches in the long run.

Understanding the need to stay informed about market reports and trends is paramount in the property management industry. As a homeowner, it's crucial for your chosen property management company to regularly analyze these reports and trends when deciding on rental rates. This enables the company to price your properties competitively and attract quality tenants. Market reports provide insights into factors like average rental rates, vacancy rates, and demand trends in your local area. These factors can significantly influence the profitability of your rental property. Therefore, it is essential that your property company uses this valuable resource to inform their decisions and strategies. If a company ignores these trends, it may lead to your property being overpriced or underpriced, both of which can negatively impact your return on investment.

Tenant Screening

Thorough tenant screening is essential to ensure reliable and responsible tenants. A management company with experience in tenant screening can save you from potential problems down the road. They will have a rigorous screening process that includes credit checks, employment verification, and rental history checks to ensure that only qualified tenants are selected for your rental property. This reduces the risk of late payments, evictions, and damages to your property.

Additionally, experienced property management companies will have a deep understanding of fair housing laws and regulations. They will ensure that the screening process is fair and unbiased, eliminating any potential for discrimination claims against you as a homeowner.

Property Maintenance

Regular and thorough property maintenance is crucial to protect your investment and keep tenants satisfied. A good property management company will have a team of reliable and trained professionals who can handle all maintenance issues promptly. They will also conduct regular inspections to identify any potential problems before they escalate into costly repairs.

Moreover, property managers are well-versed in local laws and regulations regarding property maintenance. They will ensure that your property is up to code and respond quickly to any safety concerns or complaints from tenants.

Rent Collection

Timely and efficient rent collection is crucial for maintaining consistent cash flow. Crestmont Realty handles rent collection diligently, making it easy for tenants to pay and ensuring you receive your payments promptly. Our streamlined system minimizes delays and provides you with peace of mind. In case of any delinquent payments, we have a strict protocol in place to handle the situation professionally and efficiently.

Furthermore, experienced property management companies will provide detailed reports and accounting to keep you updated on your rental property's financial health. This level of transparency enables you to make informed decisions about your investment and stay on top of any potential issues.

Legal Compliance

Navigating the legal landscape of property management can be complex. Property management companies have the knowledge and expertise to ensure that all legal requirements are met. This includes drawing up a legally binding lease agreement, handling evictions in compliance with local laws, and staying up to date on changing regulations. This helps protect you from any potential legal issues that may arise. As a San Diego property owner, you have to make sure the San Diego property management company that works for you understands the state and local housing laws.

Financial Reporting

Detailed and clear financial reporting is essential for understanding the financial health of your investment. Property management companies provide monthly statements that outline all income and expenses related to your property. This allows you to easily track your investment's performance and make informed decisions about future investments. In addition, property management companies can also handle all tax-related matters, ensuring that your records are accurate and up to date.

Here are some strategies to ensure you select the right company:

    1. Research: Start by doing some basic research. Look for companies that mention monthly statements as part of their services. Read reviews and testimonials to see if other clients are satisfied with their reporting.
    2. Ask Directly: During your initial consultation, ask about their financial reporting process. They should be able to explain how and when they will deliver your monthly statements.
    3. Request Samples: If possible, ask for a sample of a monthly statement. This will give you a clear idea of the level of detail provided.
    4. Discuss Their Approach: The company should have a proactive approach to reporting. They should not only send the statements but also be willing to explain any details you don’t understand.

By ensuring these criteria are met, you can confidently engage with their values of transparency and allows you to stay informed about your property's financial performance.


Choosing one of the best property management companies is a vital step in maximizing the return on your investment. Crestmont Realty stands out with our unique tenant screening process, regular property maintenance, efficient rent collection, legal compliance assurance, detailed financial reporting, exceptional customer service, transparent pricing structure, and years of experience in the San Diego property management sector. We invite you to choose wisely and trust Crestmont Realty with your property management needs.

To learn more about our services and how we can assist you, contact us today. Make the right choice for your property!


Stay Informed!

Sign up to get latest updates:

Next Steps: Sync an Email Add-On

To get the most out of your form, we suggest that you sync this form with an email add-on. To learn more about your email add-on options, visit the following page (https://www.gravityforms.com/the-8-best-email-plugins-for-wordpress-in-2020/). Important: Delete this tip before you publish the form.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Higher Income. Less Stress.

San Diego's Trusted Asset Manager for Owners & Investors

Let Crestmont help you start maximizing ROI today!

Compare listings