San Diego Landlord’s Guide to Insurance Coverage Options to Protect Your Property

What are the differences between homeowner’s insurance and landlord insurance and what coverage do you need for your rental property?

Table of Contents


When it comes to managing rental properties, unforeseen circumstances can arise at any time. From property damage caused by extreme weather events to liability claims resulting from tenant injuries, the potential risks are real. Landlord insurance provides the necessary protection to ensure that you’re financially prepared for such situations. It gives you the confidence to navigate the rental market with peace of mind, knowing that your investment is well-protected.

Key Take-aways

  1. Landlords in San Diego can require tenants to have renters’ insurance, providing a safety net for both parties in case of unforeseen incidents.
  2. Landlord insurance typically covers property damage, liability, loss of rental income, legal expenses, and medical payments, but the extent of the coverage can vary.
  3. When choosing an insurance policy, landlords should assess their property’s value and potential risks, compare different policies, and evaluate insurance companies based on their reputation and service.
  4. Landlord insurance policies offer varying levels of coverage. Basic coverage provides essential protection against specific perils, broad coverage expands on this by covering additional risks, and comprehensive coverage offers the highest level of protection.
  5. Beyond standard landlord insurance, other coverage options to consider include natural disaster, vandalism and burglary, fair rental value, and emergency coverage.

What is “Landlord” or Dwelling Protection Insurance?

Landlord insurance is a specialized form of insurance designed to protect rental property owners from potential risks and liabilities. It provides coverage for property damage, liability claims, and even loss of rental income. With landlord insurance, you can safeguard your investment and mitigate financial risks associated with owning rental properties in San Diego.

Landlord Insurance vs. Homeowners Insurance

While both landlord insurance and homeowners insurance provide essential protection for property owners, they cater to different needs and carry distinct features. Homeowners insurance is tailored to cover owner-occupied properties, providing comprehensive coverage for the dwelling, personal property, liability, and additional living expenses. On the other hand, landlord insurance (aka dwelling protection or rental property insurance) is designed specifically for rental properties. While it also covers the dwelling and liability, it often extends to include loss of rental income—an essential aspect for landlords if a property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss. Personal property coverage in landlord insurance typically only extends to items related to maintaining or renting the property like appliances or lawnmowers, unlike a homeowners insurance policy that covers personal contents. These differences underscore the importance of selecting the right type of insurance for your property.

Landlord Insurance vs. Renters Insurance

Comparing landlord insurance coverage and renters insurance reveals a distinct difference in protection coverage. Landlord insurance, as discussed, is designed to shield property owners from potential financial loss due to property damage, liability claims, and loss of rental income. It focuses on the structure of the building and items used for maintaining or renting the property.

Renters insurance, on the other hand, is tailored for tenants. It covers the personal property of the renter in case of damage or theft. It also includes liability coverage, protecting the renter if someone is injured within their rented unit and pursues a claim. Importantly, renters insurance does not provide coverage for the structure of the building—that aspect remains the responsibility of the landlord.

Both insurance types serve pivotal roles in the rental industry, providing security and peace of mind to their respective policyholders. As a landlord, it’s prudent to encourage your tenants to acquire renters insurance, as it complements your landlord insurance and ensures a holistic protection plan for your rental property.

Can San Diego Landlords Require Tenants to Have Renters Insurance?

Yes, landlords in San Diego can indeed require their tenants to have renters insurance. It’s a common practice in rental agreements and provides a layer of financial protection for both parties. This requirement, typically mentioned in the lease agreement, ensures that the tenant’s personal possessions, living expenses, and liability are covered in the event of unforeseen circumstances such as fire, theft, or personal injury within the rented premises. Though not legally mandated, imposing this requirement reflects a landlord’s foresight and understanding of the comprehensive security that a well-structured insurance plan offers. It’s a win-win situation, where the landlord ensures the protection of their property, and the tenant safeguards their belongings and liability.

IMPORTANT: Always consider consulting with a legal expert or property management company to ensure your lease agreements uphold the rights and responsibilities of both landlords and tenants effectively and ethically.

What Landlord Insurance Covers

Landlord coverage includes a range of potential risks and liabilities that landlords may face. It typically includes:

  • Property Damage Coverage: This protects your rental property against damage caused by perils like fire, vandalism, or natural disasters.
  • Liability Coverage: It protects if someone is injured on your property and holds you liable for their damages.
  • Loss of Rental Income Coverage: This helps compensate for lost rental income if your property becomes uninhabitable due to covered perils, such as a fire or severe storm damage.
  • Legal Expense Coverage: This provides coverage for legal expenses if you need to take legal action against a tenant.
  • Medical Payments Coverage: In case a guest is injured on your property, this covers their medical expenses regardless of who was at fault.

Choosing the Right Insurance Policy

Selecting the right landlord policy for your rental property is crucial. Here are some key factors to consider:

  • Assess Property Value and Risks: Evaluate the value of your property and the potential risks it may face. This will help you determine the appropriate coverage limits.
  • Compare Coverage Options and Deductibles: Consider different insurance policies and compare their coverage options, deductibles, and exclusions. Ensure that the policy aligns with your specific needs.
  • Evaluate Insurance Companies: Look for an insurance provider with a strong reputation, excellent customer service, and a track record of handling claims efficiently.

Typical Levels of Coverage

Landlord insurance policies often come in three levels of coverage, each offering a different degree of protection.

    1. Basic Coverage: This is the most affordable level of insurance, providing coverage against a limited number of perils. Coverage typically includes fire, explosion, lightning, windstorm, and hail. However, it excludes certain events like floods and earthquakes.
    2. Broad Coverage: This middle-tier policy includes all the protections of basic coverage, along with additional perils such as burglary, falling objects, weight of snow, ice, and sleet, water damage, and more. Broad coverage bridges the gap between basic and comprehensive policies, offering more protection at a moderate cost.
    3. Comprehensive Coverage: Offering the highest level of protection, comprehensive coverage insures your rental property against all perils unless explicitly excluded in the policy. While it comes at a higher cost, it provides peace of mind knowing that your investment property is extensively covered.

Additional Coverage Options for Landlords in San Diego

Beyond standard landlord insurance, there are specialized coverage options that San Diego landlords may consider to ensure comprehensive protection for their investment property.

  • Natural Disaster Coverage: San Diego’s geographical location exposes it to certain natural hazards such as earthquakes and floods. Standard landlord insurance policies typically do not cover these perils, so additional coverage may be necessary.
  • Vandalism and Burglary Coverage: While property damage coverage can include vandalism, landlords may opt for more extensive protection to cover unauthorized break-ins and theft.
  • Fair Rental Value Coverage: If your rental property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss, this coverage will reimburse the rental income you would have made during the restoration period.
  • Emergency Coverage: This covers unexpected costs that arise due to emergencies, such as the cost of temporary housing for tenants displaced by damage to the rental property.

Landlords should thoroughly assess their properties, consider potential risks, and review their existing insurance policies to identify any coverage gaps. By considering these additional coverage options, you can ensure that your investment is well-protected against a broad range of potential risks.


Protecting your investment as a landlord in San Diego is essential. With landlord insurance, you can have the confidence and peace of mind to navigate the rental market effectively.

Consult with a seasoned insurance broker who specializes in dwelling protection and investment properties. These professionals can provide invaluable guidance, leveraging their extensive expertise to help you understand your unique insurance needs and identify the most suitable policies. They can also assist in comparing different insurance providers, ensuring you receive the best possible coverage at a competitive price. Remember, not all insurance policies are created equal, and a tailored approach is necessary to protect your valuable investment adequately. So, take the next crucial step — consult with an expert insurance broker today to secure your investment property’s future.


The Crestmont Team


Landlord insurance typically covers property damage, liability, loss of rental income, legal expenses, and medical payments. The extent of coverage can vary depending on the chosen policy.

Landlord insurance policies often come in three levels: basic coverage, broad coverage, and comprehensive coverage. Each level offers a different degree of protection, with comprehensive coverage offering the highest level of protection.

Yes, there are specialized coverage options such as natural disaster coverage, vandalism and burglary coverage, fair rental value coverage, and emergency coverage. These options can provide more comprehensive protection for landlords in San Diego.

When choosing an insurance policy, landlords should assess their property’s value and potential risks, compare different policies, and evaluate insurance companies based on their reputation and service.

Landlords in San Diego should consult with a seasoned insurance broker who specializes in dwelling protection and investment properties. These professionals can provide invaluable guidance, help understand unique insurance needs, and identify the most suitable policies.

Yes, landlord insurance policies are often customizable to cater to the unique needs and circumstances of each property. This allows landlords to add or modify coverage options based on the specific risks associated with their properties.

Generally, landlord insurance covers damage caused by tenants as long as it was unintentional or the result of a specific covered peril. However, intentional damage caused by tenants may not be covered. It’s always best to review your policy details or consult with your insurance provider for clarity.

In most cases, expenses related to landlord insurance are considered a legitimate business expense and are therefore tax-deductible. However, specific rules may vary, so it’s advisable to consult with a tax professional.

The cost of landlord insurance is typically determined by several factors including the property’s value, location, construction type, the extent of coverage selected, and your claims history.

While both homeowners insurance and landlord insurance provide coverage for property damage, they differ mainly in terms of occupancy. Homeowners insurance is designed for properties where the owner resides, while landlord insurance is intended for properties rented out to tenants. Landlord insurance often includes additional coverages relevant to rental activities, such as loss of rental income and liability protection.


Stay Informed!

Sign up to get latest updates:

Next Steps: Sync an Email Add-On

To get the most out of your form, we suggest that you sync this form with an email add-on. To learn more about your email add-on options, visit the following page ( Important: Delete this tip before you publish the form.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Higher Income. Less Stress.

San Diego's Trusted Asset Manager for Owners & Investors

Let Crestmont help you start maximizing ROI today!

Compare listings